Please wait as we prepare your PDF file ....

Mission Chronicle Blog

Search Blog

our goal is to help you stay informed by providing timely and interesting articles.

NAR files motion to dismiss ‘bombshell’ buyer-side lawsuit

05/20/2019

Download PDF

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) announced over the weekend it has asked a judge to dismiss the bombshell class-action lawsuit that accuses both the trade group and major real estate companies of conspiring to determine buyers’ agents’ compensation.

In a statement, NAR explained that it wants the suit thrown out because it “misrepresents” the organization’s rules that govern multiple listing services (MLSs). The statement argues these rules “have long been recognized by the courts across the country as protecting consumers and creating competitive, efficient markets.”

John Smaby

NAR President John Smaby added in the statement that members of the organization and MLSs “promote a pro-consumer, pro-competitive market for home buyers and sellers, contrary to the baseless claims of these class action attorneys.”

Home seller Christopher Moehr filed the lawsuit in March. In addition to NAR, it accuses real estate heavyweights Realogy, HomeServices of America, RE/MAX and Keller Williams of violating the Sherman Antitrust Act. The problem, according to the suit, is that NAR and these various firms all require brokers to make a “blanket, non-negotiable offer of buyer broker compensation.”

“The conspiracy has saddled home sellers with a cost that would be borne by the buyer in a competitive market,” Moehr’s complaint goes on to argue. “Moreover, because most buyer brokers will not show homes to their clients where the seller is offering a lower buyer broker commission, or will show homes with higher commission offers first, sellers are incentivized when making the required blanket, non-negotiable offer to procure the buyer brokers’ cooperation by offering a high commission.”

Millennials can differ by age: what agents need to know Two distinct groups of millennial buyers: why they differ and how to work with them READ MORE

However, in its request that the lawsuit be dismissed, NAR argues that mischaracterizing the rules led Moehr’s attorneys “to ‘dream up’ purportedly anticompetitive rules that simply do not exist in NAR’s Handbook or Code of Ethics.”

NAR also argues that it directs listing brokers and their clients to determine the amount of compensation to offer buyers’ agents. Moreover, NAR continues, a buyer’s agent “is free to negotiate a commission from the listing broker that is different from what appears in the MLS listing.”

“Ultimately, these rules create a system of highly competitive markets where consumers receive superior service,” NAR added in its statement.

NAR ultimately refers to Moehr’s lawyers as “career class action attorneys” and describes the suit as sitting on “shaky legal grounds” that disregard “legal precedents that have upheld the pro-competitive benefits represented by the MLS system.”

Smaby added that NAR’s filing “shows the lawsuit is wrong on the facts, wrong on the economics and wrong on the law.”

Email Jim Dalrymple II

Source: click here

Read More

INSPIRED, INTELLIGENT, INSIGHTFULL

STAY INFORMED WITH TIMELY AND INTERESTING ARTICLES FROM OUR BLOG, MISSION CHRONICLE. OUR ASPIRATION IS TO PROVIDE REALTORS AND OTHER REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY PROFESSIONALS WITH EXCEPTIONAL RESOURCES AND SHARE OUR KNOWLEDGE TO PROPEL YOU TO YOUR GOALS.

  • Mission Chronicle Newsletter July 24, 2023

    Mortgage rates continued to press downward last week after the previous week's CPI data pointed to e...

  • Mission Chronicle Newsletter Feb 20, 2023

    Despite the recent downward trend in mortgage rates and hopes that the Fed was nearing the end of it...

  • Mission Chronicle Newsletter Feb 6, 2023

    The Federal Reserve meeting ended as market participants expected, with a quarter-point increase and...

  • Mission Chronicle Newsletter Dec 26, 2022

    Mortgage rates held relatively steady last week as most economic news came in better than expected.C...

  • Mission Chronicle Newsletter Dec 12, 2022

    Rates managed to move slightly downward last week as recession fears grew amid hopes that the Fedis ...

  • Mission Chronicle Newsletter Dec 5th 2022

    Mission Chronicle Newsletter Dec 5th 2022. Platforms: Browser, mobile-responsiveIdeal for: Leasing a...

  • Inman Review: Tenants and leasing teams get better connected with RentTango

    Have suggestions for products that you’d like to see reviewed by our real estate technology ex...

  • Tech Review: Smart Alto puts people first in its innovative lead qualification solution

    Have suggestions for products that you’d like to see reviewed by our real estate technology ex...

  • Refreshed and nurture-savvy, Market Leader’s CRM deserves your attention

    Have suggestions for products that you’d like to see reviewed by our real estate technology ex...

  • The top 4 tips to improve your negotiation skills

    In today’s luxury real estate market, strong negotiation skills are an asset—you might even say ...

October 2024
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

  • Polls

    What information you are looking for?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
  • Last month Results

    How Is My Site?

    • Good (100%, 3 Votes)
    • Excellent (0%, 0 Votes)
    • Bad (0%, 0 Votes)
    • Can Be Improved (0%, 0 Votes)
    • No Comments (0%, 0 Votes)

    Total Voters: 3

    Vote

    Loading ... Loading ...